Aristotle, Rhetoric and Poetry based on the Pseudology

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Kashan University

Abstract

The relationship between rhetoric and poetry has been the subject of experts’ controversy since the beginning of the controversy, and this controversy has continued to this day without reaching a definite conclusion. The root of such controversy lies in Aristotle's two treatises on rhetoric and poetry. In these two treatises, the general boundaries between these two techniques are drawn and their minor boundaries remain invisible.
In this descriptive-analytical method, while examining the commonalities and differences between the two rhetoric and poetry techniques, the present article tries to study the separation of their specific rhetorical techniques based on the two treatises of rhetoric and Aristotle's poetry. This article concludes that the art of rhetoric and the art of poetry, in addition to the commonalities and differences in generalities, components, materials, types, theologians, audiences, and styles, have more to do with the use of rhetorical techniques than the sharing of materials and differences; That is, the working materials of these two techniques
Are generally common, and the purpose of using these materials in them is different.
 

Keywords

References

- Aghayani Chvoshi, Lila & Aghayani Chavoshi Roohollah (2016/1395). “Mystical Text As Rhetoric: Analyzing The Rhetoric Dimension With Emphasis On Metaphor & Allegory: (matn-e erfa̅ni be masa̅be-ye xeta̅be Barresi-e voju̅h-e xeta̅bi dar sa̅xta̅r-e motu̅n-e erfa̅ni ba̅ ta̕ kid bar este̕ a̅re va tamsil)”. Literary Criticism and Rhetoric. Vol 5 . Issue 1 . Spring & Summer. Pp189-206.
- Ahmadsoltani, Manizhe (1991/1370). “Technical Ode and Image Creation khaghani Shervani: (qaside-ye fanni va tasvir a̅farini xa̅qani-e šerva̅ni)” Keyhan.
- Ahmadi, Mohammad (2017/1396). “The Nature of Rhetorical Criticism and its Importance in Literary Studies: (ma̅hiyat-e naqd-e retoriki va ahmmiyat-e a̅n dar mota̅le ̕ a̅t-e adabi)”. Belaghat Karbordi va naghd Belaghi. Vol 2. Issue 1. Spring & Summer. Pp73-87.
- Akbari, Zeynab & Raja, Abu Ali (2019/1397). “Rhetorical Allegory in the Light of Various Rhetorical Approaches: (bela̅qat-e tamsil dar partov-e ru̅ykard-ha̅-ye moxtalef-e bela̅qi)”. Linguistic and Rhetorical studies. Vol 9. Issue 18. Autumn and Winter. Pp 7-38
- Amini, Mohammad Reza (2009/1388). “A critical review of the fundamental concepts of semantics (Ma’āni) or traditional study of the literary theory: (ba̅znegari-e maba̅ni-e elm-e Ma’āni va naghd-e bardašt-ha̅-ye ra̅yej-e a̅n)”. textual criticism of Persian Literature. Vol 1. Issue3. Autumn. Pp 59-76.
- Anvari, Ali Ibn Mohammad (1994/1372). “diva̅n-e anvari”. Ed.By: Mohammad Taghi Modarres Razavi. Elmivafarhangi.
- Aristotle (1990/1369). “Poetics: (fann-e še ̕ r)”.Tr.By: Abdolhosein Zarrinkoub. 2nd ed. Tehran. Amirkabir.
- Aristotle (2014/1393). “Rhetoric: (fann-e xeta̅be)”. Tr.By: parkhide Maleki. 3rd ed. Tehran. Eghbal.
 Farabi (1988/1408 AH). “almanteqiya̅t lelfa̅ra̅bi”. Ed. By: Mohammad Taghi Danesh Pazhouh. With the Effort of seyed Mahmoud Marashi. Vol 1. 1st ed. Qom. Maktabat Ayatollah Marashi Najafi.
- Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (2003/1382SH). “Speech Method: (a̅ien-e soxanvari)”. 4th ed. Tehran. Zavvar.

- Fotouhi, Mahmoud (2007/1386). “A Critical Look on the Theoretical Principles and Methods of Traditional Rhetoric: (nega̅hi enteqa̅di be maba̅ni-e nazari va raveš-e bela̅gat-e sonnati)”. Adab pazhuhi. Vol 2. Issue 3. Autumn. Pp 9-38.

- Ghanouni, Mohammad Reza & Gholamhoseini, Parvin (2017/1396). “Investigating and Analyzing the Reflection of Folklore (Proverb) in the Novels of Jalal al-Ahmad: (adabiya̅t-e a̅me zarb-ol-masal-ha̅ va kena̅ya̅t va ba̅zta̅b-e a̅n dar roma̅n-ha̅-ye jala̅l-e a̅l-e ahmad)”. Linguistic and Rhetorical studies. Spring & Summer. Pp 117-140.

- Halabi, Aliasghar (1998/1377). “The Influence of Quran & Hadith in Persian Literature: (ta̕ sir-e qora̅n va hadith dar adabiya̅t-e fa̅rsi)”. 5th ed. Tehran. Asatir
- Helli, Hasan Ibn Yousof (1994/1373). “Johar-al-nazid” Tr. By: Manochehr Sane̕ i Darehbidi. 2nd ed. Hekmat.
- Ibn Rushd (1986). “talxis-e keta̅b-al-še̕ r”. Ed.By: Charls Petrores & Ahmad Abdolmajid Haridi. Cairo. Alheat Almesriyat Alamat lelketab.
- Ibn sina (1984/1404 AH). “aššefa̅-al-manteq”. Vol 4. Qom. Maktabat Ayatollah Marashi Najafi.
- Ibn sina (2004/1383). “A treatise on logic Alais encyclopedia: (resa̅le-ye manteq-e da̅nešna̅me-ye a̕ la̅ie)”. With the Edition and Explanation by: Mohammad Mo̕ in & seyed Mohammad Meshkat. Hamedan. Bu Ali Sina university.
- Kennedy, George A. (1994). A New History of Classical Rhetoric. Prinston University Press.
- Makaryk, Irena Rima (2006/1385). “‎Encyclopedia of contemporary literary theory: (da̅neš na̅me-ye nazariye-ha̅-ye adabi-ye mo̕ a̅ser)”.Tr. By: Mehran mohajer & Mohammad Nabavi. 2nd ed. Tehran. Agah.
- Mir Fenderski, Abu Taleb Ibn Mirza Beik (2002/1381). “resa̅le-ye Baya̅n Badi̕ “.With the Effort. Edition and Explanation by: Seyed Maryam Rowzatian. 1st ed. Esfahan. Daftar Tablighat Eslami.
-Mozaffar, Mohammad Reza (2012/1433 AH). “Logic: (al-manteq)”. Explanation by: Gholam Reza Fayyazi. With the Effort: Rahmat Allah Rahmati Araki. 8th ed. Qom. Eslami.
- Naser khosrow (1991/1370). “diva̅n-e naser xosrow” Ed. By: Mojtaba Minovi & Mahdi Mohaghghegh. Tehran University.
- Plett, Heinrich F. (2010). Literary rhetoric:concepts-structures-analyses (Vol. 2). Brill.
- Pratkanis, Antony R & Aronson, Elliot (2001/1379). "Age of propaganda: the everyday use and abuse of persuasion:(asr-e tabliqa̅t su̅ ̕-e estefa̅de ru̅zmarre az eqna̅ ̕ ). Tr. By: Kavoos Seyedemami & Mohammad Sadegh Abasi. 4th ed. Tehran. Soroosh.
- Rastgo, seyed Mohammad (2014/1393). “The Manifestation of Quran and Hadith in Persian Poem: (tajalli-e qora̅n & hadith dar še̕ r-e fa̅rsi)” 11th ed. Tehran. Samt.
- Taheri, Mohammad (2012/1391). “A Study of Plato's and Aristotle's Views on Criticism of mimesis & Art of Poetry: (Barresi-e a̅ra̅-e afla̅tu̅n va arastu̅ dar naqd-e moha̅ka̅t va honar-e ša̅ ̕eri)”Kavoshnameh. Vol 13. Issue 24. Spring & Summer. Pp9-42. 
- Toohey, Peter. (1994). Epic and rhetoric.Persuasion: Greek rhetoric inaction. Ed. Ian Worthington.  London, UK: Routledge. 153-175.
- Tousi, Nasir-Al-Din (2010/1389SH). “asa̅s-al-eqteba̅s”. 1st ed. Tehran. Ferdows.
- Vaez kashefi Sabzevari, Mirza hosein (1990/1369). “bada̅ye̕ -al- afka̅r fi sana̅ye̕-al-aš̕ a̅r” Ed.By: Mir Jalalodin Kazzazi. 1st ed. Tehran. Markaz. 
- Wardy, Robert. (2005). The birth of rhetoric: Gorgias, Plato and their successors. Routledge.
- Zarghani, seyed Mahdi (2012/1391). “Classic Pottery: (botiqa̅-ye kela̅sik)”. 1st ed. Tehran. Sokhan.
- Zarrinkoub, Abdolhossein (2004/1383). “serr-e ney”. 10th ed. Tehran. Elmi.
The Journal Of Linguistic and Rhetorical Studies
Volume 11, Issue 21
June 2020
Pages 333-362

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics